Monday, 19 November 2007

Learning to read

The current labour government is criticising the Tory party for their pronouncement that testing should ensure all children have learnt to read to an acceptable basic standard by the age of six or seven. There is of course the utterly correct supposition that not all kids thrive on testing. But the really big point I am finding difficult to get past is: Six is so very bloody old to learn to read, let alone seven!
I'll happily admit that this may come across as idealist snobbery, but children should should be reading a round about three or four. I personally think that teachers should be expecting that all kids should arrive at school with reading as a skill. Now I don't think that this needs to be an empty politicians promise, it surely would save money to catch those that need extra help reading early and give them a little help before they arrive at school behind. I would like to see the statistics on how many children learn to read by when and any research on why. I would like to know if my knee-jerk reaction that there is a significant cadre of children who arrive at school without having had any proper guidance in reading is correct. I say guidance rather than "being taught" because there is a big body of evidence that suggests children don't benefit from early formal learning (this is the line that the teaching unions are using) but my personal experience is that children want to learn to read, they want to be in the club of deciphering those enigmatic runes. The problem is it takes time and effort, reading stories, sounding out words, playing with phonetics, being willing to spend the time and effort all day every day to help the children in your life to do that sounding out and answer the questions. This is why I may go looking for research in this area, to see how many hours each week an ordinary parent spends helping their child to read and how many parents in this day and age have the extended family or support network of friends to give their ankle-biters the best start in life.
Recently many conversations I have had with new acquaintances have been about the contrasts between the old concept of right and left and how the political compass gives the whole thing another dimension, well this is an issue I am firmly in the authoritarian camp on, the state should do its utmost to ensure parents are kept in line and help their children to read, with any learning difficulties identified early and appropriate assistance rendered. Any parent deliberately not engaging with encouraging this most fundamental of skills, far more so than understanding science or mathematics as hugely valuable as they are as building blocks, is tantamount to child abuse and should lead to the same amount of scrutiny from social services.

34 comments:

  1. I hear that on much of the continent they don't bother teaching reading until about 6, and the children then surpass ours very quickly.

    It may have something to do with English spelling, which is ripe for reform IMHO.

    ReplyDelete
  2. B can't read - and she is almost 4. She recognises letters, loves stories and books - but she can't read. We are probably bad parents :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. unfortunatly I can't do the looking up of research on the internet I wanted to do until I escape the jury suite. Might bring my laptop tomorrow.
    So I can't say how realistic having a level of reading for every child before school is.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Well - I guess I'll have to let you off then :)

    Also it depends on what you define 'reading' as - letter recognition - basic phonics - short words - several short words - sentance recognition [I'm not an expert in primary edu :) ]

    I would *love* B to learn to read, but as we do the nursery thing 3 days a week - at the mo - we tend to follow the curriculum they set and re-inforce that at home.

    I'm very much against 'testing' - by all means collect indicative data to show... but testing *shudder*

    ReplyDelete
  5. I could read (to, say, a Famous Five level) before I went to primary school. I could read Ladybird books about dinosaurs (including all the long classicalist names) before I went to nursery. By age seven, I was onto the Hobbit and Day of the Triffids.

    However my mum was a qualified primary school teacher who had a complete set of textbooks from see-spot-run upwards, and she dedicated a significant amount of time to forcing a grumpy toddler to do work. I'm not sure I could do the same for my putative children.

    R.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Our kids have been in nursery from age 4 months - so very little chance of being able to read before that! :D

    ReplyDelete
  7. Our kids have been in nursery from age 4 months - so very little chance of being able to read before that! :D

    ReplyDelete
  8. I teach in primary education and am personally very worried about the levels of children's reading skills. When I taught reception class (the year after nursery) only 2 out of my 30 children were able to 'read' by word recognition and sound-blending. Very few children in the class knew their alphabet, so it meant that I was starting teaching at a very basic level. (The government do not take this into account when they tell you the levels expected by certain ages!)
    Some children in my class had never held a book before, so had to be taught how to hold a book, turn the pages etc.
    On leaving my reception class and moving to Year 1, all children could recognise their letter sounds (alphabet) and about half were able to read simple books with some fluency. The remainder of the children varied from being able to blend the sounds together to make words and a small percentage who still failed to grasp this concept and relied upon telling the story through pictures. Some of these children were then highlighted as having special needs.
    I feel that ideally all children entering school should recognise letters and know the corresponding sound. This would give a firm foundation for building upon in terms of reading and writing. This means time spent at home which many parents simply don't seem to have (or some feel it's not their job!)
    It has a knock-on effect through school as we are expected to teach specific skills at specific ages, and if the early skills are lacking, then this means the new skills are lost on a large number of children. As teachers we are foced to move on so quickly and the poorer children are often left behind.
    I became very fed up of parents coming to school to complain about a lack of progress by their children, when they spent no time with their children at home. They saw it as a teacher's job to ensure their children read fluently. We can only do so much and parents need to take responsibility.
    I feel it important that children should develop a love of books and I would find lots of times throughout the day to share story books with my class. I think I probably read about five on average through the course of a day. Management frowned upon this as a waste of time, but I stood by it. I know a lot of teachers caved under pressure and were lucky if they shared a book once every few days.
    Seems that people want results quickly these days but don't want to put in the effort to get there.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The blog is well researched; however a few grammatical errors can be spotted. You can improvise your skills by seeking academic assistance from MyassignmenthelpAU offering exceptional assignment help. The services offered are reliable yet cost effective, exclusively for students overseas.

    for more info: Assignment Help Liverpool

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks for all the tips mentioned in this article! it’s always good to read things you have heard before and are implementing, but from a different perspective, always pick up some extra bits of information. for More Information Click Here:- HP Printer Error 79

    ReplyDelete
  12. Reading is always been a part of writing, if reading skills are weak writing will be poor too. Thanks for sharing this article, it will increase the skills of paper help professionals.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  14. when i got admission in college, i was not good in reading and starting days of college my teacher gave me information technology assignment help task. I was worried but i tried for better. I started reading articles, novels and different books and this habit help me.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Reading is such an important skill and having someone help you learn it can be incredibly beneficial. Plus, Pay Someone To Take My Algebra Class can save you time and energy.

    ReplyDelete
  16. It's a significant contribution! I really anticipate all of the information. This is exceedingly beneficial and instructive. I value the effort and time that you put into writing this. It's well worth reading. I'll make sure to tell others about it. Grateful you for your input. This is something I will definitely come back to in the future. I'm definitely picking up some new information. Excellent work! Continue your excellent work.
    ¿Qué es un divorcio de mutuo acuerdo en Virginia?
    divorcio indiscutido sin culpa en virginia

    ReplyDelete
  17. Timly inventory software that helps you stay on top of inventory management, material planning, production scheduling, and more.
    Inventory Management Software

    ReplyDelete
  18. We design, manufacture, distribute and install custom cabinets for customers in Denver Colorado USA

    custom Cabinetry

    ReplyDelete
  19. Embarking on the journey of learning to read has been truly rewarding! No need to resort to 'Pay someone to do my assignment' when the joy of understanding words unfolds with each page turned. Knowledge gained through personal effort is priceless.

    ReplyDelete
  20. We are JPA M&E Consultants, a Building Services Engineering Consultancy practice, operating out of the United Kingdom with offices in London, Edinburgh and Newcastle. Our team of highly experienced Chartered Building Services Engineers and Sustainability Consultants started this practice to give our clients a unique, responsive MEP Design service. We operate closely with M&E Contractors and Developers to bring a holistic design experience to the project.

    M&E Consultants

    ReplyDelete
  21. "TheGreatGonzo" delivers a captivating mix of bold, irreverent commentary and deep dives into pop culture, making it a go-to source for engaging content. Its unique voice and witty perspective set it apart in the world of digital media Traffic Lawyer Botetourt VA

    ReplyDelete
  22. Looking for top-tier laser eye surgery? Blue Fin Vision® on Harley Street, London, offers cutting-edge procedures like LASIK, PRK, and SMILE. With advanced technology and a patient-first approach, they help people achieve crystal-clear vision without glasses or contacts.

    Lens replacement surgery

    ReplyDelete
  23. It’s an interesting debate for sure — and it makes me think about how different learning styles affect kids’ development. It’s a bit like embroidery digitizing in a way — stay with me here — where you can’t expect one single design file to work perfectly on every type of fabric. Some materials handle dense stitching beautifully, while others pucker and pull, needing a gentler, more tailored approach. Kids are the same — some thrive with structured testing, while others need a more flexible, creative path to unlock their potential. The idea that six or seven is "too old" to read really highlights how important it is to recognize those different learning curves — not force every child through the same rigid pattern.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Investing in gold coins like the Sovereign from London Gold Centre is a smart way to safeguard wealth. The coin's value is supported by both the global demand for gold and the enduring popularity of the Sovereign’s design.

    Sovereign Gold Coin Best Value UK

    ReplyDelete
  25. Public opinion on SASSA has been mixed. While many beneficiaries are grateful for the assistance provided, sassa status check
    criticisms regarding delays, poor service delivery, and corruption persist.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Download Whatsapp 2025 to unlock a range of exciting features like customization options and improved privacy controls.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Not all hair clinics are created equal—WMG London offers advanced tech and personalized care, which makes a huge difference in both outcome and experience. A great choice if you're serious about restoring your hair.

    hair transplant London

    ReplyDelete
  28. The LESCO online bill viewing Click here
    system is a simple yet powerful service for every electricity consumer in the LESCO region. I

    ReplyDelete

  29. RoyalDTF’s expertise in DTF printing helps entrepreneurs and artists bring their creative ideas to life with vibrant colors and durable materials.









    Order DTF UK

    ReplyDelete
  30. This thought-provoking debate on early literacy highlights how educational policies shape future outcomes—much like how strategic thinking in business programs drives career success. For MBA students in Dubai analyzing such socio-educational frameworks, MBA assignment help Dubai provides the research and structuring needed to craft impactful arguments. A compelling read that underscores the lifelong value of foundational skills, whether in reading or business acumen!

    ReplyDelete
  31. Tax payable to zero but won't result in Disability Tax Credit Canada
    a cash refund if you owe no tax—unless you're transferring it to a family member or claiming retroactively.

    ReplyDelete
  32. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  33. YouTube automation is a growing online business model where creators build faceless YouTube channels by outsourcing tasks like scripting, voiceovers, and video editing. Success in YouTube automation https://www.nexlev.io/is-youtube-automation-worth-it often depends on choosing the right **YouTube automation niches**, such as finance, tech, or motivation. These niches are ideal for scaling channels without creating content yourself. By focusing on high-demand topics and optimizing for engagement, creators can generate passive income through ad revenue, affiliate marketing, and sponsorships.

    ReplyDelete
  34. This was a really engaging read — totally agree that early reading is a foundational skill and should be nurtured well before school age. It reminds me how we often underestimate kids’ ability to absorb complex things when they're interested. Just like how some young teens navigate story-driven games like Summertime Saga Mod APK unlock all, which involve reading, decision-making, and memory — it shows how immersive environments can motivate learning, even outside traditional classrooms. Maybe we need more creative tools like that to support early literacy and engagement.

    ReplyDelete